|
Traditional Marking Methods for Manufacturing and Engraving
Scribing
Definition: A process utilizing a hard-tip (like diamond)pen or pointed device to scratch or scrape off the surface of a material to generate a mark.
Advantages: It is possible to generate deep engravings with this type of process. Being a traditional marking method, scribing is generally an inexpensive process.
Disadvantage: Compared to Laser Marking, scribing is a slow and crude process. Precesion, high resolution marking is impossible with scribing. Also, many materials can be damaged or deformed through this process, which includes anchoring the part using clamps or fasteners. Scribing involves purchasing replacement tips when they wear out.
Inkjet Printing
Definition: A process whereby inks and/or dyes are sprayed through nozzles onto the surface of the part to create a mark.
Advantages: Being a traditional marking method, scribing is generally an inexpensive process. Also, high speed (although low resolution) marking can be achieved with inkjet printing.
Disadvantage: Compared to Laser Marking, inkjet printing is a messy process with many comsumables, including, replacement nozzles, ink refills and clean up materials. Although inkjet printing does not generally damage the part, the marking will fade or rub off over time, making it illegible. In general, high resolution, permanent marking is a challenge for inkjet. Inkjet printing poses another key disadvantage in the medical field where sterility is important, particularly in implantable medical parts and devices. Most inks are considered to be harmful contimants to the body.
Chemical (Acid) Etching
Definition: A process where acid is applied through a stencil to corrode the part, leaving a mark.
Advantages: It is possible to generate permanent marks with this type of process.
Disadvantage: Compared to Laser Marking, chemical etching is a messy and caustic process. Users are constantly exposed to acids and chemicals which are harmful to touch and breate in. Precesion, high resolution markings are nearly impossible with chemical etching and there are numerous consumables such as replacement stencils and acid refills.
Stamping
Definition: A process where a single metal stamp or series of pin stamps is struck into the part to leave a physical impression, thereby leaving a mark.
Advantages: Stamping is generally very fast. It is also possible to generate deep permanent markings with this process. Being a traditional marking method, scribing is generally an inexpensive process.
Disadvantage: Compared to Laser Marking, scribing is a crude process where part damage and resolution are a constant challenge. Precesion, high resolution markings nearly impossible with stamping, particularly on smaller parts. Also, many materials can be damaged or deformed through this process, which includes anchoring the part using clamps or fasteners. Stamping involves purchasing replacement stamps when they wear out.
|
|